The Royal Navy in the Mediterranean 1900-1915

 
 

"The Millstone"

The "Straits" Trilogy by Geoffrey Miller

 

 

Please click to go to "The Millstone" web-site

 

Admiral Sir John Arbuthnot Fisher
Admiral Sir John Arbuthnot Fisher

THE MILLSTONE
British Naval Policy in the Mediterranean, 1900-1914, the Commitment to France and British Intervention in the War

At half past two on the afternoon of Sunday, 2 August 1914, Sir Edward Grey, the Foreign Secretary, informed the French Ambassador of the decision just reached by the British Cabinet — despite not yet being at war with Germany, if, nevertheless, the German High Seas Fleet ventured out from its base, the British fleet ‘would intervene … in such a way that from that moment Great Britain and Germany would be in a state of war.’ What led to the giving of this pledge? Was there an obligation on Britain’s part, or merely a commitment, moral or otherwise, to intervene in certain circumstances? The Foreign Secretary subsequently declared in his own defence that the promise to the French ‘did not pledge us to war.’ Grey was, however, wrong — once the promise was made, British entry into the war was certain. Despite this, a group within the Cabinet spent the afternoon of Sunday 2 August desperately searching for an issue around which they could group, and which would provide a more convenient excuse for British entry into the war than one based upon a moral commitment to France; that excuse was to be Belgian neutrality.


Two things virtually guaranteed British entry in the war: the secret Anglo-French military and naval talks, which commenced in 1906, and the naval position in the Mediterranean. With Austria and Italy both constructing dreadnoughts, and facing the German naval challenge, British command of the Mediterranean could no longer be guaranteed. Similarly over-extended, the French were unable to protect both their Atlantic and Mediterranean coastlines. From strategic necessity came political expediency. The Millstone will show:
 

  • That Grey was more aware of what was settled by the secret military conversations than he pretended to be.
  • That the situation created by the German naval programme gave Britain no option other than to evacuate the Mediterranean.
  • That Anglo-French naval co-ordination and strategic planning remained chaotic.
  • That the Cabinet could not have prevented Britain’s entry into the war; all they could have done was to prevent the formation of a coalition Government.
  • That the pledge to France and consideration of British interests were the sole determinants of Britain’s entry.
  • That the German promise in August 1914 not to attack the French coast was irrelevant.
  • That, far from informing the German Government of the pledge given to Cambon as he claimed, Grey was determined to conceal this fact until Monday, 3 August.
  • That the issue of Belgian neutrality was used in August 1914 to assuage consciences and prevent the formation of a coalition Government, but was not crucial to the decision to intervene.
  • That the Continental policy, committing British troops to fight in Europe, was decided upon in August 1911 by a small inner circle of the Cabinet who knew precisely what it would entail.  

 

 

 

"…I don’t like the Mediterranean! However, there’s no mistake about it that the Mediterranean is the tip-top appointment of the Service, and, of course, if there’s war, there’s a peerage or Westminster Abbey. But it’s pretty sure to be Westminster Abbey."
Admiral Sir John Fisher
23 March 1899


"The Mediterranean is of necessity the vital point of a naval war, and you can no more change this than you can change the position of Mount Vesuvius, because geographical conditions, Sebastopol and Toulon, and the Eastern question, will compel the Battle of Armageddon to be fought in the Mediterranean."
Admiral Sir John Fisher
1 December 1900


"As to the policy of reducing the Mediterranean Fleet, the matter is most simple. The margin of power in the North Sea is irreducible and requires this addition of the Mediterranean battleships … We cannot have everything or be strong everywhere. It is futile to be strong in the subsidiary theatre of war and not overwhelmingly supreme in the decisive theatre. The moral effect of an omnipresent fleet is very great, but it cannot be weighed – at least in the Cabinets of the Powers – against a main fleet known to be ready to strike and able to strike hard."
Admiral Sir John Fisher
24 June 1912

 

 

 

Please click to go to "The Millstone" web-site The Millstone
British Policy in the Mediterranean, 1900-1914, the Commitment to France

and British Intervention in the War
xv + 611 pages
Full bibliography, notes and index
Laminated card cover, 5" x 8"
ISBN 0 85958 690 1
Published 1999
 

For an overview of Superior Force (remaining within this web-site), please click:

Please click for an overview of The Millstone

To go to the dedicated web-site for "The Millstone", please click:

Please click to go to "The Millstone" web-site
The full text is available on-line at www.the-millstone.co.uk

 

Please click to go to the top of this page

 

HMS Dublin
HMS Dublin (Captain John Kelly)
Light cruiser, First Cruiser Squadron, Mediterranean Station, 1914

 

The Links Page :

As the range of our activities is so diverse, we have a number of different websites. The site you are currently viewing concentrates on the three non-fiction books written by Geoffrey Miller, dealing with British Naval Policy in the Mediterranean from 1900 to 1915. The main Flamborough Manor site focuses primarily on accommodation but has brief details of all our other activities. To allow for more information to be presented on these other activities, there are other self-contained web-sites. All our web-sites have a LINKS page in common, which allows for easy navigation between the various sites. To find out where you are, or to return to the main site, simply go to the LINKS page.

Please click to go to the top of this page

 

 

HMS Berwick : Original artwork  2004 Geoffrey Miller
HMS Berwick
[Original artwork 2004 Geoffrey Miller]

 

Geoffrey Miller can be contacted by:

Telephone or FAX
01262 850943  [International: +44 1262 850943]
 
Postal address

The Manor House,
Flamborough,
Bridlington,
East Riding of Yorkshire, YO15 1PD
United Kingdom.
 

E-mail
gm@resurgambooks.co.uk
Please click to go to the top of this page

 

Home Superior Force Straits The Millstone Ordering
Table of Contents Synopsis Synopsis Synopsis Order Form
Search Contents Contents Contents Links
Feedback Introduction Introduction Introduction Reviews
Biographies Essay   Summary Go to web sites
Bibliography Timeline     Order Form PDF
Copyright 1995-2013.
Please note that all rights are reserved and that no part of this publication may be further reproduced by any means without the prior permission of the author, Geoffrey Miller, who has asserted his right in accordance with sections 77 and 78 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988 to be identified as the author of this work.

Web-site design & content Copyright  1995-2013 Geoffrey Miller